PRC's 70th anniversary parade
Beneath the facade of strength, unity and national rejuvenation
|Sep 26, 2019|
Over the last few weeks, I have been asked repeatedly what we should expect from the October 1 parade. Here I want to talk about this occasion against broader trends instead of focusing on glitzy weapons.
Weapons, weapons, weapons
But let’s get the weapons out the way first…
Researchers at the Foundation for Strategic Research in Paris have done a great job at analysing satellite images for clues on the new weapons that would be unveiled.
Based on these images, the highlights will be advanced missiles and UAVs, including the DF-41 next-gen ICBM, DF-17, a launcher for the DF-ZF hypersonic glider, the JL-2 SLBM, and a range of new drones.
First, China’s nuclear modernisation is making substantial progress. This progress is both in terms of quality and quantitive of its nuclear arsenal. Essentially, China’s nuclear force is becoming more mobile, resilient, reliable, technologically advanced, and diversified (in terms of missile systems, as well as moving away from a sole reliance on land-based nuclear forces). This makes China’s nuclear forces more secure against a first-strike, thus adding to the credibility of its nuclear deterrent by ensuring a second-strike retaliatory capability. I have written about China’s nuclear forces at length here (especially page 166-170).
Second, China’s growing conventional military capability, including missiles, information forces, and air and naval power is increasingly making it hard for the US to sustain its military edge in regional scenarios. The US military is still far more advanced than the PLA, but the PLA is closing the gap across the spectrum of capabilities and eroding the US military advantage in Asia. Also, US forces are spread across the globe whereas China can focus its military in its neighbourhood. What this means is that the conventional balance in military power, in relative terms, is tipping towards China. Hence, the PLA is more likely to deter the US from using force in regional scenarios, such as with respect to Taiwan and the South China Sea.
Finally, the parade will focus on showcasing domestic manufactured weaponry. Amid the trade war and rising technological competition between China and the US, Beijing wants to send the message that it is now a formidable technological power with the scientific and industrial foundations to support its ambition of creating a world-class military. In the past, much of China’s advanced military equipment came from abroad. Increasingly, these advanced systems are developed and manufactured in China (some with technology acquired via covert means).
A Party in a pressure cooker
Okay, having dealt with weapons and strategic signalling, let’s move on to other important stuff: CCP legitimacy, challenges, and the storm looming on the horizon.
70th anniversary is a very important occasion, especially given the domestic and international context in which this occasion is celebrated.
Domestically, Beijing faces formidable economic challenges, including intractable structural issues. And it faces the colossal task of ensuring that the expectations of the people for a better life are satisfied. After all, this is a key pillar of CCP’s legitimacy. Xi during the 19th CCP Party Congress stated that the principal contradiction facing Chinese society has evolved from “the ever-growing material and cultural needs of the people and backward social production" to “unbalanced and inadequate development and the people's ever-growing needs for a better life”.
This is not ideological mumbo jumbo - it is actually very important. Principal contradiction refers, in Marxist-Leninist parlance, to what the party should be preoccupied with as its top priority. Essentially, the CCP is admitting that in order to keep power, it needs to keep the people happy. To me, the party is a tired hamster on the wheel of material progress.
At the elite politics level, we are likely to see a further sidelining of the role of Deng, Jiang and Hu in building modern China. I suspect we will see a further sanitisation of the history of the PRC to suit Xi; drawing a straight line from Mao to Xi - from revolutionary beginnings to the threshold of national rejuvenation. This emphasis is not new. The party has already rewritten the history of the reform era. History is consistently been examined, struggled over, and rewritten in the People’s Republic. Indeed, on October 1, this will be on full display with all the accompanying symbols and rituals of Xi’s new era.
Beyond mainland China, the CCP is facing, what essentially amounts to, an open rebellion in Hong Kong without an end in sight; a recalcitrant Taiwan with a looming election; and an international environment that is decisively less hospitable. US-China competition is for the long term; the trade war is just a symptom of deeper trends. Other regional countries, such as Australia, Japan and India are also anxious about China’s power and are adjusting their strategy to better protect their interests, sometimes to the chagrin of Beijing.
Shadows loom large
The story of the 70th anniversary that the CCP wants to tell is a pretty simple one: over the last 70 years since the establishment of the PRC, CCP has led the Chinese people to rise and stand up; today China is more powerful than any time in recent history; and under Xi, China is finally on the threshold of achieving national rejuvenation; the road ahead will be difficult, but the time for greatness is imminent.
This story pandas to nationalism, which has been on full display, most palpably in the unfolding crisis in Hong Kong. But beneath the facade of confidence, unity and strength, the party-state is paranoid about the accumulating political risks, social tensions and frustrations, and the myriad of domestic and international challenges.
This year alone, Xi has warned party officials of “black swans” and “grey rhinos” risks; launched a political education campaign for the party and military officials; and called on the party to steel itself for protracted “struggles”. These are not signs of confidence. CCP perceives itself to be under assault - by both internal and external foes.
On the occasion of the 70th anniversary of the PRC’s founding, shadows loom large over China. China’s political order, hybrid economy and social stability are all more brittle than one may assume. For all we know, the fuse may or may not have already been lit.